Whether you have naturally full brows or sparse ones, an eyebrow pencil adds the perfect final touch to your makeup look. Properly filled-in brows will make you look put together, and you’ll feel more confident than ever. Choosing the right product is key, so we’ve gathered ten of the best eyebrow pencils below.
All ten of the eyebrow pencils on our list have been tested and positively reviewed by users; they’re long-lasting, natural-looking, and easy to use. We only chose products that are under $25, so they won’t break the bank. These days, many eyebrow pencils are more like gels or brushes, which makes it even easier to get the natural full look. Check out our picks for the best eyebrow pencils ranked from most to least expensive below, and elevate your brows at long last.
10. Wunderbrow D-Fine
Wunderbrow specializes in high-quality eyebrow products, so it’s no surprise that we’re featuring two of their products on our list. Our first pick comes in at $22.80 on Amazon, and it features an eyebrow pencil at one end and eyebrow gel at the other. Use the pencil to define and shape your brows, and use the gel to fill in the hairs. This product allows you to be precise, and you’ll get long-lasting fuller brows. We recommend this product for professionals or experienced users.
9. Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
This product resembles a mechanical pencil, and is just as easy to use. It’s just $23.95 on Amazon, and features a grooming brush on one end. This is maybe the best drugstore eyebrow pencil. The Maybelline eyebrow pencil has similar quality to other high-end eyebrow pencils, and delivers a subtle but long-lasting pigment that’s easy to apply and blend. Users love the natural shades, and since its look isn’t too dramatic, it’s great for beginners and professionals alike.
8. Wunderbrow Brow Gel
Lucky for you, our second Wunderbrow pick is even more well-loved than the first, and it’s more affordable too. Our number 8 best eyebrow pencil, Wunderbrow’s Brow Gel is just $20.90 on Amazon. Brow gels might seem more intimidating than traditional eyebrow pencils, but they’re actually even easier to use. Just brush on color the same way you’d use mascara. Wunderbrow’s formula features natural hair-like fibers, and it lasts for an impressive three days. This product is easy to use, and great for beginners.
7. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
At $21, this eyebrow pencil is worth the money for its ease of use and attractive results. This product has a self-sharpening pencil and a brush, so it’s easy to deposit color and then blend with the brush as needed. The resulting eyebrows will look full, but not dramatic, so your eyebrows will still look natural. It’s water-resistant, too, so your brows will stay in place all day. Beginners and professionals alike love this product; it’s often ranked as one of the best eyebrow pencils out there. Because of its price tag, it comes in at seventh on our list. You can find it on Amazon.
6. Queen of the Fill Tinted Eyebrow Makeup Gel Cruelty Free
For a step up from your average eyebrow product, try this tinted eyebrow gel product from Queen of the Fill. At $15 on Amazon, this product is loved by users for its natural, buildable shades. The gel defines your brows, deposits color and adds dimension all at the same time. It’s also long-lasting, so you won’t need to touch up throughout the day. We recommend this product for makeup lovers of all experience levels.
5. HeyBeauty Eyebrow Pencil with Brow Brush, Waterproof Automatic Makeup Cosmetic Tool
Our fifth best eyebrow pencil is this $8.99 waterproof eyebrow pencil from HeyBeauty. This product has a retractable angled pencil that’s easy to use, and a brush on the other end for grooming and taming your hairs. It’s long-lasting and won’t smudge. Users love the selection of shades, and the fact that it’s easy to use, even for beginners. It’s available online on Amazon.
4. Etude House Tint My Brows Gel
For $7.30, this is a truly unique eyebrow product. It features a wand formula, so you can draw on your brows the same way you would use liquid eyeliner. The difference with this product is that it deposits a tint onto your brows, so even after you take your brows off, a subtle color remains. This is a great option for those who want their eyebrow look to last all day and night. We recommend this for professionals, since you’ll need to be precise when applying this extra-long-lasting color. Buy it online on Amazon.
3. Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil & Gel by ColorStay
This $4.72 brow product duo comes as our third best eyebrow pencil, because it offers attractive results for a low price. It features a medium-sized pencil on one side, and a tinted brow gel on the other side. The brow gel helps your brows stay in place and provides overall color, while the eyebrow pencil defines your line. Though not waterproof, this product will last you throughout the day. It’s a great option for professionals or beginners who want an affordable, reliable brow product. Find it on Amazon.
2. Etude House Drawing Eye Brow
Our second best eyebrow pencil comes in at just $4.08 on Amazon. At that price, it’s a steal! This product features a pencil at one end and a brush on the other end. The pencil on this product is more thick, so it can be easier to use for those who don’t want to bother trying to make precise brush strokes. It can be layered to be as light or dark as you choose. Users love the way the pencil applies, and the fact that it’s hard to make a mistake. Consider it our pick for the best eyebrow pencil for absolute beginners.
1. Best eyebrow pencil – NYX Auto Eyebrow Pencil
Our number one pick for the best eyebrow pencil is the NYX auto eyebrow pencil, which is available for just $3.74. This pencil is similar to many of the higher-end eyebrow pencils out there, including some on this list. It features a pencil and brush in one. At a fraction of the price, it’s hard to argue with this being the best option for those who want to be beautiful on a budget! The pencil deposits light color, so it’s buildable and easy to use for beginners, and the brush helps comb your hairs into place. Your full brows will stay on all day. This product is a standby for new and experienced users alike. You can buy it on Amazon.
Your brows are unique, so choose the product that works best for your specific needs. Have you tried any of these products? What other brow products do you absolutely love? Share your thoughts with us in the comments section below!