Liner is one of the most important steps in a beauty routine. A cat-eye flick can do so many things, and so many looks have been defined by a simple black line. Gathered below is a list of the best eyeliners on the market, perfect for your morning routine, or for dramatic evening looks! The products below have been chosen for their affordable prices and high rankings online. You will find liquid and gel options, as well as pencils, suitable for beginners. All have received overwhelmingly popular reviews, and will amp up your makeup look without breaking the bank. Below you can find the best eyeliner for you.
10. e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner
e.l.f. is a brand that is constantly associated with low prices and high quality. Clocking it at 5 stars with a price tag of around $8 for a pack of two, this product is no exception. The liquid formula glides on easily, removing the need to tug and pull at the delicate skin of your eyelids. Additionally, the fine-tip brush creates rich, precise lines, and can be used for either natural or dramatic effects. The defined look will last all day, and this is easily the best liquid liner in e.l.f.’s arsenal.
9. Rimmel’s Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner
Rimmel’s smooth and creamy kohl formula provides long-lasting, shockingly bold color intensity. Water-proof, smudgeproof, sweat-proof, heat-proof, and humidity-proof, this rich eyeliner can withstand all conditions and last for hours on end. At around $3 on Amazon, it comes in three shades – a rich black, a sweet nude, and a stunning purple. With a 3.7 rating and hundreds of positive reviews, this might be one of the best pencil eyeliner options available on the market
8. NYX Cosmetics Collection Noir Liquid Liner
This collection is focused entirely on black liners, ranging in textures from matte to glossy. With a price tag of around $5, this liner defines eyes and can enhance any look, or create bold lines that make anyone stand out. With a rich and long-lasting formula, the liner is waterproof and smudgeproof, and lasts through any activity – the best eyeliner for active users!
7. Palladio’s Liquid Eyeliner in Black Shimmer
Available in nine shades and costing around $6 with a 4.3 ranking on Amazon.com, this liquid liner is versatile and highly pigmented. Available in rich shades of black, brown, blue, and purple, this liquid liner adds dramatic eye definition. Some of its colors are shimmery, and some are matte, giving it a wide selection that is not available with most brands. With its easy-to-grip wand and a firm, felt-tip applicator, drawing thick or thin lines is easier than ever before. The smear-proof and long-lasting formula ensures that it lasts throughout the day – or night. The product is available on Amazon.
6. Maybelline’s New York Eye Studio Master Graphic Liquid Eyeliner
This liner is bold and brilliant, the best for graphic designs and sharp wings. The pen’s shape lends itself perfectly to the drawing of perfect lines. The pitch-black finish won’t smear or smudge, and the chiseled edge means your line can be as delicate or as bold as your own personal style. With a price tag of around $6, and 3.7 stars on Amazon, this product is perfect for those who want to create unique, graphic designs. It is also one of the best drugstore liquid eyeliner options that we recommend.
5. Super Slim Eyeliner by Loreal Paris
Available on Amazon for around $7 and ranked at 4.1 stars, this super-fine liner is one of the best eyeliners for creating flawless and clean lines. The ultra-fine felt tip delivers the perfect amount of product, and the intensely black formula dries quickly, and glides on smoothly with a continuous, even flow. Staying put for over twelve hours, this is certainly one of the most long-lasting liners on the market. The precise lines, as thin as 0.4mm, make this pen one of the best eyeliners for creating sleek and sophisticated looks. It is the best smudge-proof eyeliner, suitable for creating perfect cat eyes.
Recommended read: How to Apply Eyeliner: 14 Insanely Simple Tips
4. Revlon’s ColorStay Eyeliner with SoftFlex
At around $6, and 4.1 stars on Amazon, this is one of the best drugstore eyeliner pencil options. Available in a rich, black-brown shade, it accentuates every eye, and turns up the volume on any look. The SoftFlex technology makes application comfortable and easy, and the pull-out sharpener means you never have to worry about the edges going dull. The waterproof formula won’t smudge, smear, or fade away, and the colors remain rich and vivid for up to sixteen hours.
3. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
Maybelline’s best eyeliner gel sells on Amazon for around $8, and has user ratings of 4.2 stars, worthy of a place on the best eyeliners list. While it may not come in as many colors as other brands, it offers four shades in black, grey, brown, and deep eggplant purple. All four shades have intense color payoff, thanks to the highly concentrated pigments. While there may be some price variation – the black, charcoal, and eggplant shades sell for around $7 apiece, these are still a steal, and can make any look pop. With a smudge proof, water proof formula that allows for 24-hour wear, this is one of the best eyeliners on the market.
2. L’Oreal’s Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner
This gel liner comes in five different shades – a rich black, a deep espresso, a stunning bronze, a smoky slate, and a brilliant navy blue. Whether you have blue, green, or brown eyes, you will surely find the right shade for you with L’Oreal Infallible. While the price points vary, this is almost the best eyeliner earning consistently high-rankings of 4.5 stars. The intense, high-shine finish glides on smoothly, and the intense pigment provides 24-hour shine.
1. Best Eyeliner – Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Black
While this clocks in at $22.00, making it the most expensive product on the list, Stila’s best-selling product has a cool 4.1 rating, and comes in fifteen shades, stretching across every color of the rainbow. With its felt tip applicator, the pigment glides on. Stila’s liner is also one of the best on the market – and experts agree. It’s the best eyeliner for everyone, makeup beginners or experts – it delivers dramatic lines and rich color. While it may be a little pricier than the average liner, this vivid, smudge-proof pen is well-worth the investment.
The liners above are perfect for all levels of makeup artistry, from beginners to professionals. They are great for any look, be it clean or smoky, night or day. All of the above eyeliners are highly ranked on Amazon – and hopefully, when you add them to your own makeup bag, you’ll see why!
Have these already? Do you have any other products to recommend? Have your own opinion on the best eyeliner? Let us know in the comments!